Apr 222026
 

Note: This story is from my book Highway History and Back Road Mystery

The last stagecoach robbery in the United States took place in 1899, in Arizona. The holdup stands out in history not just because it was the last of its kind, but also because it is the only stagecoach robbery on record by a woman bandit!

Pearl Heart was a rebel in a time when women were expected to spend their days raising children and keeping the home fires burning. That sort of life never appealed to Pearl, and she quickly took another course.

Born Pearl Taylor to a wealthy family in Ontario, Canada, Pearl attended the finest schools and seemed to be headed for a comfortable life as a businessman’s wife. But Pearl never did what was expected of her. She fell in love with a gambler named Frederick Hart and ran away from home. The couple headed for the Columbian Exposition in Chicago. Frederick Hart turned out to be an unskilled gambler who couldn’t win a hand of poker if he was the only person sitting at the table. Pearl worked odd jobs to support them, while Frederick lost whatever she earned in card games.

Enthralled with the Wild West shows playing at the Exposition, Pearl became infatuated with the myths and legends of the Old West. She left Frederick just as quickly as she had left her family and headed for Colorado. No sooner did she arrive than she realized she was pregnant, and returned to her family in Canada. By now she was calling herself Pearl Heart, a takeoff on Frederick Hart’s name, though it is uncertain if they were ever legally married.

Pearl stayed in Canada just long enough to give birth to a son, then she quickly left the baby with her parents and headed for Arizona. Soon after, Frederick Hart tracked her down and convinced her it was time to settle down into a conventional life. Frederick took a job as a hotel manager in Phoenix and they lived a quiet life for five years or so, even adding a daughter to their little family. It is doubtful either was really content, and in 1898 Frederick left the family and enlisted in Teddy Roosevelt’s Rough Riders and went off to fight in Cuba.

She returned to her family in Canada, and in a repeat of her earlier actions, quickly left her children behind and headed off seeking new adventures, surfacing in various Arizona mining camps and taking whatever work she could find, legal or otherwise.

Pearl hooked up with a miner named Joe Boot and told him she needed to raise money to help her sick mother back in Canada. The two hatched a plan to rob the stagecoach that ran between Florence and Globe. The neophyte desperadoes thought the job would be easy pickings.

As the stage rattled through the desert, Pearl and Joe stepped into its path with guns drawn and ordered the driver to stop. While Joe Boot guarded the driver, Pearl, dressed in men’s clothes, ushered the stage’s passengers out at gunpoint and relieved them of $450. Then they jumped on their horses, fired a warning shot and were off in a cloud of dust.

While the robbery went off as planned, neither Joe nor Pearl were experienced with anything that went on outside the boundaries of a boom town or mining camp. They quickly became lost and rode around in circles for a day or two until a posse caught up with them.

Lodged in the Globe jail, Pearl played the role of lady outlaw to the hilt. Crowds gathered to see this petite and attractive woman, asking for her autograph. What bandit queen can be content sitting in a jail cell? Certainly not Pearl Heart, and within a week or two she and a prisoner named Ed Hogan escaped.

Pearl had not learned anything about navigating the wilds of the Arizona frontier while incarcerated, and soon she was recaptured and taken back to jail. But the escape and subsequent manhunt helped spread her legend and solidified her self-proclaimed role as a lady outlaw.

Pearl’s trial was held in Florence, and it was obvious her romantic image had swayed public opinion in her favor. After deliberating a short time, the jury returned with an acquittal. Judge Doan was not nearly so taken with Pearl, and he quickly vacated the jury’s verdict and empaneled a second jury, warning them not to be influenced by Pearl’s gender and to concentrate on the facts of the case. This jury found the lady bandit guilty, and she was sentenced to five years in the Yuma Territorial Prison. Her partner in crime, Joe Boot, was sentenced to thirty years behind bars.

She was one of 29 women who served time at the prison over the years. She appears to have been a model prisoner, and after eighteen months she was paroled. Some stories say she was released because she became pregnant, and the Arizona Territory did not want the scandal to become public knowledge.

Pearl went to Kansas City, where she attempted to cash in on her notoriety by playing herself in a stage drama of her life. Her fame lasted only a few weeks, then she dropped out of sight for a while. A year or so later she was arrested again, this time under the name of Mrs. Keele, and charged with receiving stolen property. The next anyone heard of her was in 1924, when Pearl returned to Globe, Arizona and toured the old jail where she had been held years before.

From there Pearl’s fate is a mystery. Some claim she married an Arizona rancher and lived out her days in a peaceful life where few knew of her past. Another story has her dying in San Francisco in 1925. No one really knows for sure. But one thing is certain, in the lore of the Old West, Arizona’s Lady Bandit will live on forever.

Did you know that you can find all of my books and sign up for my free author’s newsletter on my website at www.nickrussellbooks.com?

And finally, here’s a chuckle to start your day from the collection of funny signs we see in our travels and that our readers share with us.

Thought For The Day – We’ve been married so long, we can now fight without even speaking.

Nick Russell

World-Famous, New York Times Best Selling Author, and All-Around Nice Guy!

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.