Outlaw Grave

 Posted by at 12:54 am  Nick's Blog
Mar 032026
 

They call the White Mountains of east-central Arizona a sportsman’s paradise. The dense Ponderosa pine forests are home to a variety of wildlife, from bear and mountain lions, to elk, deer, antelope, and many varieties of small game. The numerous lakes and rivers are full of trout, bass, and other species of fish. Besides hunters and anglers, it’s also a popular area with people who love the outdoors.

One popular recreation area for those who are willing to put in a little effort to get there is the Black River, a 114-mile-long stretch of river that begins near Alpine and flows through rugged canyons and high-elevation forests at over 7,400 feet.

There is a lot of history here, from our hometown of Show Low, which was named after a card game, to stories about gunfighters, lawmen, pioneers, and Native Americans. For adventurers going to the east fork of the Black River, an interesting stop is the lonely grave of outlaw Oscar Shultz.

There is quite a bit of debate about Shultz, but some facts are known for sure, including that he was born in Germany in 1896 and immigrated to America, settling down in Arizona. Some people say he was a hardworking ranch hand, while others say he was a ne’er-do-well, always looking to make an easy buck. Or maybe he was a little bit of both. Who knows?

At any rate, in the spring of 1922, this was still wild country where people traveled on horseback as much or more than they did in automobiles. One story says that Oscar’s mother, still living in Germany, wrote him and said she was living in desperate poverty and needed help. Other stories say that he was just drawn to a life of crime. No matter what the motivation was, Oscar is reported to have begun his crime spree by robbing a man at gunpoint near Springerville. Supposedly he got less than $5, which would be about $96 in today’s money. Some claim that he immediately felt remorseful and gave the money back. Whether that was true or not, the crime was reported to the sheriff at St. Johns, in Apache County, and a posse was formed to hunt down the outlaw.

With the posse drawing near, Oscar abandoned his horse and hid in a tree. Fanning out through the underbrush, the posse was soon scattered over a wide area. As the story goes, the sheriff happened to ride under the tree Oscar was hiding in, and when he stopped to drink from his canteen, Oscar jumped out of the tree and stole the sheriff’s horse at gunpoint.

Oscar then made his way to the small town of McNary, and robbed the bank there of approximately $100, then fled into the Big Lake area. More men joined the posse, and Oscar was hard-pressed to evade capture. Coming upon the Blue Lookout station, south of Hannagan Meadow, he stayed there with the ranger overnight. The next morning, the 17th of May, members of the posse caught up with him.

The story differs again here. Some versions of it say that Oscar came out of the lookout station shooting, while others say he was unarmed, exhausted, tired of running, and willing to surrender. Either way, he was shot to death by members of the posse.

Loading the dead outlaw’s body onto the back of a horse, the posse started back to town. After two days of navigating their way through the rough country in the warm mid-May weather, Oscar’s body began to get pretty ripe. Again, some say they buried him in a shallow grave there, while others claim they simply dumped his body on the ground and kept on riding, and that a local rancher who knew Oscar buried him.

The grave can be found near the junction of Forest Roads 276 and 8083. From Alpine, Arizona, go north on Highway 191 one mile to Three Forks Road (FR 249), then go west 4.7 miles to FR276 and turn left. Go south, then west for 3 miles to FR 8083. The grave is to the left, off the road, surrounded by white fencing. GPS coordinates are 33°49’39.5″N 109°15’59.8″W

One final note is that in this rough, remote area, cell phone reception is almost impossible, except at Oscar’s grave. People familiar with the area say that when they are camping or fishing along the Black River and need to make a phone call, they go to the gravesite, where they can always get a signal.

Did you know that you can find all of my books and sign up for my free author’s newsletter on my website at www.nickrussellbooks.com?

And finally, here’s a chuckle to start your day from the collection of funny signs we see in our travels and that our readers share with us.

Thought For The Day – There is a fine line between catching an outlaw and becoming one.

 

 

Nick Russell

World-Famous, New York Times Best Selling Author, and All-Around Nice Guy!

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.